Combi vs Conventional Boilers: Pros and Cons
- What is a combi boiler?
- What is a conventional boiler?
- Don’t forget about system boilers
- Combi vs conventional boiler
- Combi vs conventional boiler costs
- Best combi boilers
- Best conventional boilers
- Why replace a conventional with a combi boiler?
- Which boiler is right for you?
- Get free boiler installation quotes
Comparing a combi vs conventional boiler will help you find the best heating system for your home.
One of these will be far more suitable for your home than the other. Most homes turn to a combi boiler but, if you have two or more bathrooms, then you could be better off with a conventional (regular) boiler. This is because they store hot water in a cylinder so can meet higher demand. But if you don’t already have a regular boiler, avoid them. Instead, go for a combi boiler or, if you have a high demand for hot water, then a system boiler – which are a modern take on the regular boiler.
There’s plenty to think about so let’s compare combi and conventional boilers.
What is a combi boiler?
A combi boiler delivers heating and hot water on demand. One of their biggest benefits is that they don't need to be fitted alongside any tanks or cylinders, so they don’t take up much space. Everything they need to heat your home and hot water is within the boiler itself.
While the space-saving qualities of a combi can't be understated, they do have their limitations. To meet high demands for domestic hot water, conventional and system boilers are installed alongside a hot water cylinder. As combi boilers work by heating and send hot water to a top on demand, they struggle to meet high demand.
What is a conventional boiler?
The conventional boiler goes by many names – regular, heat-only and open-vent, to name a few – and is the oldest boiler type. As well as the boiler, a conventional heating system also includes tanks in the loft and a hot water cylinder.
A tank in the loft is full of cold water, which is delivered down to the boiler or cylinder as and when it needs to be heated. Then the cylinder is where the domestic hot water is heated and stored until a hot water tap is turned on.
As you can tell, plenty of space is needed for a conventional boiler and all of its external parts. So you'll need the room available in your property. Plus, all of these parts are connected by a unique and complex network of pipes. For this reason, a conventional boiler is often only recommended for properties considering a direct conventional-to-conventional boiler replacement.
Don’t forget about system boilers
Comparing combi vs conventional boilers doesn't tell the whole story. System boilers are also be worth considering.
System boilers offer the best of both worlds in the sense that they're directly connected to the mains water supply and store water in a cylinder. This allows them to meet high demands for hot water without the need for a tank in the loft.
Combi vs conventional boiler
Now that we know the difference between combi and conventional boilers, let's consider what they can each offer your home. As well as what you need to keep in mind.
Combi boiler pros and cons
For homes with a single bathroom (possibly two depending on the output rating) a combi boiler is the best option for these reasons:
- You’ll be saving space
- Hot water will be sent to the taps as and when you need it
- Installation is straightforward and relatively quick (2 days max)
- A combi-for-combi boiler swap is the cheapest boiler replacement
As great as combi boilers are, they're only suitable for small to medium sized homes. Larger properties with multiple bathrooms should instead turn to a conventional or system boiler. And here's why:
- Can't meet the hot water demands of homes with multiple bathrooms
- Not suitable for homes with weak mains water pressure
Conventional boiler pros and cons
You should only consider a conventional boiler if you already have one installed. This is because the pipework won't need to be replaced making the installation far more straightforward. Benefits of installing a conventional boiler include:
- Homes with 2 or more bathrooms will have plenty of hot water
- The latest models reach high levels of efficiency
As well as the potential pros, there are plenty of considerations to make before installing a conventional boiler:
- No instant access to hot water
- Space for the boiler, cylinder and tanks in the loft will be needed
- If there’s no hot water in the cylinder when you want a bath, you’ll need to wait for it to fill up again
- Water in the cylinder can lose heat when in the cylinder so you need to make sure that it's well insulated
- Installation can be lengthy and costly
Combi vs conventional boiler costs
When it comes to costs, the combi boiler is the more affordable option. A combi boiler will cost somewhere between £500 and £2,000 while conventional boiler prices can stretch to £2,750. System boiler prices tend to go up to £2,500.
Installation of a combi boiler is pretty straightforward and won’t take too long (at a stretch it can be completed in a day but 2 days is more realistic as the installer should perform a powerflush). Plus, you'll be saving between £600 and £1,000 as you won't need a hot water cylinder.
As well as the boiler itself, you'll also need to consider the installation costs. A like-for-like boiler replacement is would be your cheapest option. This means replacing a combi boiler with another combi, for example.
|Boiler type||Average cost of boiler excluding installation||Average labour cost of boiler installation||Approximate total cost of boiler fully installed|
|Combi||£500 - £2,000||£500 - £1,000||£1,000 - £3,000|
|Conventional||£500 - £2,750||£500 - £1,000||£1,000 - £3,750|
|System||£500 - £2,500||£500 - £1,000||£1,000 - £3,500|
Best combi boilers
The best combi boilers are made by:
All of these boiler manufacturers offer a range of combi boilers to choose between but the table below shows which ones are arguably the best. Within these ranges are a few different models, which explains the list of output ratings.
|Best combi boilers||CH Outputs (kW)||DHW outputs (kW)||Efficiency||Warranty|
|Baxi 800||21.2, 26.4||25, 30, 36||93%||10 years|
|Ideal Vogue Max||18, 26, 32||26, 32, 40||93%||10 years|
|Vaillant ecoTEC Plus||20.4, 25.7, 30.1, 32.2||25, 32, 35, 38||94%||10 years|
|Viessmann Vitodens 200-W||25.4, 32||30, 35||94%||Up to 10 years|
|Worcester Bosch Greenstar i||24||25, 30||93%||Up to 10 years|
Best conventional boilers
The best conventional boilers are manufactured by the same brands as the best combi boilers: Baxi, Ideal, Vaillant, Viessmann and Worcester Bosch. Some of the ranges are different though.
Unlike combi boilers, conventional boilers don’t have a domestic hot water (DHW) output. This is because they aren’t heating hot water on demand when you turn the tap on. So you only have to think about the central heating (CH) output.
|Best conventional boilers||CH outputs (kW)||Efficiency||Warranty|
|Baxi 800||16, 25, 30||93%||10 years|
|Ideal Logic Plus Heat||12, 15, 18, 24.2, 30.3||93%||7 years|
|Vaillant ecoTEC Plus 400||12.3, 15.1, 18.3, 24.6, 30.5, 35.1||94%||10 years|
|Viessmann Vitodens 100-W Compact||13, 16, 19, 26, 35||94%||Up to 10 years|
|Worcester Bosch Greenstar 8000 Life||30, 35, 40, 45, 50||94%||Up to 12 years|
Why replace a conventional with a combi boiler?
A combi boiler is a single cost-effective heating system so you'll be able to free up space by removing the tanks and cylinder. Plus, the combi boiler itself can be tucked away in a kitchen cupboard.
Replacing a conventional boiler with a combi is a great way to modernise your heating system. You'll free up space around your home and get hot water on demand. Even better, you'll no longer have to wait for the cylinder to fill with hot water before you can have a bath.
Installing a combi in the place of a conventional boiler takes a lot of work. In total, this can take as long as 4 days. So, your best bet is to book the boiler replacement during the summer to avoid being without heating during the winter.
Which boiler is right for you?
When it comes to a combi vs conventional boiler, the winner will depend on the size of your property and demand for domestic hot water.
A combi boiler is the best option for homes with 1-2 bathrooms. Meanwhile, conventional boilers can meet higher demands for hot water in properties with over 2 bathrooms thanks to the cylinder.
Then there's the system boiler. A system boiler gives you the best of both worlds: hot water storage in a cylinder and no need for tanks in a loft.
Installing the right boiler for your home is essential. Otherwise, your heating bills will rise unnecessarily or it could fail to meet demand. To avoid this, you'll also need to get the output rating spot on too.
Boiler output rating, measured in kilowatts, shows the power of the boiler. Combi boilers have a central heating (CH) output and a domestic hot water (DHW) output while conventional and system boilers only have a CH output rating.
Suitable combi boiler output rating
|Number of Radiators||Recommended combi size (CH output)|
|Up to 10||24-27 kW|
Suitable conventional boiler output rating
|Number of radiators||Recommended regular size|
|Up to 10||9-18 kW|
Find out more in What Size Boiler Do I Need?.
Get free boiler installation quotes
Have you been able to crown a winner in the battle between a combi vs conventional boiler? Then now is the time to get quotes. Even if you haven't been able to decide then a Gas Safe registered engineer is best suited to your home.
By completing our simple online form, you can get free quotes from heating engineers in your area. Up to 3 different heating companies will be in touch with you as soon as possible to arrange the quotes.
Once you have the quotes, you'll be in a position to compare them. Comparing quotes will put you in the best position when it comes to finding the most qualified boiler installer at the best price.